[Jeff H]

[ QUOTE ]
We have had good and bad expressed about both from many well respected people like yourselves so I have decided to leave it up to him.

[/ QUOTE ]

You're right Joel, there are good and bad points about both methods so it really does come down to personal preference. I think as a restorer you'll probably need to try both methods at some point in time so you know what to offer your customers. I've seen how good the dipping process works so I wouldn't have it done any other way. I think some of the earlier dipped cars may not have been properly prepped which led to problems. If you look at the pictures of my car after being dipped and cleaned up, I don't see any problems with replacing the roof insulation since it's so easy to get to. Most of the old insulation is usually rotted, moldy or eaten by animals anyway.
]