Doing restorations across Canadian border?

[SS427]

Has anyone had experience sending a Canadian car to the states for a restoration? I am curious how the GST tax is handled when a car comes across that is only valued at say $30k and goes back to Canada fully restored. Does the border nail you on GST tax because of the increased value upon it's return? Thanks in advance for any help.
Rick

[JChlupsa]

I would think if the car is still owned by the same person that any taxes have already been paid. Lets say you come south for vacation. while your down here, someone slashes all your tires. You replace them with brand new ones. They dont charge you anykind of Tax since you have new tires on the car. I know bad example but again I would think that as long as it was not sold and still in the owners name that sent it they shouldnt tax it. Also a car thats coming down for restoration would take a while and I really dont think they keep pictures of cars to see what kind of shape they return in. I would make sure that the plates/registration are up todate and wont expire while its down here though.

[SS427]

I have just heard stories about Americans driving into Canada, installing all sorts of speed equipment and then returning to the states. The border finally saw what was going on and starting taxing the heck out of them.

I am hoping to do a restoration on a car from Canada and the owner is concerned that he will be taxed outrageously due to the increase in value. Just trying to put him at ease.
Rick

[Chevy454]

So, you're saying they could be taxed twice? They could drive down, pay sales tax on the parts in the States...and yet you'd have to pay taxes again when you cross the border back to Canuckville, for what? Property tax? Can't be sales tax, the goods were sold in the US so that goes to Uncle Sam...could Canada really charge a tax for not doing anything?

[Don_Lightfoot]

Well Rick, you are opening a real can of worms on this one. A question I generally get asked when returning from the U.S. with my car on the trailer is "Did you make any improvements to the car when you were in the United States?" I take the car over four or five times a year normally.

Now, what your customer says when returning is up to him. If he declares an amount for restoration work then he will likely be charged the 7% GST tax and will be required to pay it at the border.

If he and you decide to "fudge" the amount then that is up to the two of you. Keep in mind the Canadian Customs may follow up on the information provided.

One very important thing is to have the car registered and plated in Ontario (I think that is where you said it was). In order to do that the car would need a Provincial Safety Inspection which may be difficult given the information you sent me in a PM the other day based on the condition of the car. If you bring the car back without any Ontario Plates then a whole new can of worms will be opened. They will likely suspect the car was just purchased south of the border. Another important thing, make sure the owner is with the car each time it crosses the border. You don't need any brokerage headaches to go along with all the rest of the crap.

Now, if the owner is going to claim everything, then the plating, etc. mentioned above may not be necessary.

GENERAL NOTE - With all the old cars being purchased and then taken back across the border one way or the other, the two Customs Agencies are getting wise as they know all the prices being declared are being fudged. I have just heard a rumour in the last week or two that Canadian Customs will require an appraisal from the United States source area and then another one once it gets up here. Taxes will then be based on those figures. This is not really relative to your circumstance, but thought I would throw it in to give you an idea of what's going on these days.

Bottom line - do your homework in advance and contact both Canadian and American Customs Agencies to know exactly what is involved. Probably a good idea to have the owner do this.

Good luck pal.

[Lynn]

"Excuse me,... but I do believe that sucks a$$"

Eric Cartman

[Chevy454]

What in the heck is Canada taxing? Is it a capital gains type tax, or property tax, or because of the exhange rate, or...?? This slow-thinking Hillbilly can't see how/why Canada gets to tax anything in this situation...

[camarojoe]

[ QUOTE ]
So, you're saying they could be taxed twice? They could drive down, pay sales tax on the parts in the States...and yet you'd have to pay taxes again when you cross the border back to Canuckville, for what? Property tax? Can't be sales tax, the goods were sold in the US so that goes to Uncle Sam...could Canada really charge a tax for not doing anything?

[/ QUOTE ]

Totally off subject, but think how much in taxes is paid on cars right here in the USA...EVERY time a car changes hands that same car is taxed... If a single car is bought and sold enough times, "the man" can easily end up with as much in sales taxes on the car as its original purchase price when owner #1 initially BOUGHT it... I always thought that was quite the racket, and that sales tax should only be charged on new cars, when they are first sold to customer #1...after that you're paying tax on something that was already taxed once (or twice or 3 times!) Wishful thinking I know, but it seems silly that the sale of the same car can be taxed over and over again every time its transferred to a different person.

[Chevy454]

I agree, Joe...I've griped about that for years...used to be, in Arkansas you only paid sales tax on new cars...but I believe they changed that a couple years back.